Platform Engineers

Implementing High Availability in Prometheus: Strategies and Best Practices

Platform Engineers's photo
Platform Engineers
·

4 min read

High Availability (HA) in Prometheus ensures continuous metric collection, alerting, and querying capabilities despite component failures. By design, Prometheus operates as a single-node system, making HA a non-trivial task requiring deliberate architectural decisions. This article outlines strategies and operational practices to achieve HA without relying on centralized coordination or compromising data integrity.

Strategy 1: Redundant Prometheus Instances

Deploying multiple identical Prometheus instances is the foundational approach to HA. Each instance independently scrapes the same targets using identical scrape_configs, ensuring no single point of failure.

Implementation Steps:

  1. Configuration Synchronization: Use version-controlled configuration files or configuration management tools (e.g., Ansible, Terraform) to ensure all instances share the same scrape_configs, rule_files, and alerting settings.

  2. Target Scraping: Configure targets to be discovered uniformly across instances using the same service discovery mechanisms (e.g., Kubernetes endpoints, Consul). Avoid instance-specific modifications to prevent data divergence.

  3. Deduplication Handling:

    • Alertmanager Clustering: Route alerts from all Prometheus instances to a clustered Alertmanager setup (detailed in Strategy 3). Alertmanager deduplicates alerts using grouping and inhibition rules.

    • Query Layer: Use tools like Thanos Query or Grafana to aggregate data from multiple Prometheus instances, applying deduplication logic based on timestamps or instance identifiers.

Considerations:

  • Clock Synchronization: Ensure all instances use Network Time Protocol (NTP) to minimize timestamp discrepancies.

  • Resource Allocation: Distribute instances across failure domains (e.g., availability zones, nodes) to mitigate correlated outages.

Strategy 2: Remote Storage Integration

Local storage in Prometheus is ephemeral and instance-bound. Integrating remote storage decouples data persistence from individual instances, enabling durability and long-term retention.

Implementation Steps:

  1. Configure remote_write: Enable the remote_write feature in Prometheus to forward metrics to systems like Thanos Receiver, Cortex, or M3DB. Example configuration:

     remote_write:
   - url: "http://thanos-receive:10908/api/v1/receive"
     queue_config:
       max_samples_per_send: 5000

  2. Storage Layer HA: Deploy the remote storage backend with redundancy. For example:

    • Thanos: Use Thanos Receiver with replication enabled.

    • Cortex: Deploy Cortex with multi-replica ingesters and distributed object storage (e.g., Amazon S3, Google Cloud Storage).

  3. Retention Policies: Define retention periods in the remote storage layer rather than relying on Prometheus’ local storage.

Considerations:

  • Network Latency: Monitor write latency to avoid backpressure impacting Prometheus scrape performance.

  • Data Consistency: Validate remote storage systems handle duplicate samples (e.g., via deduplication hooks or idempotent writes).

Strategy 3: Alertmanager Clustering

Alertmanager manages alert routing, silencing, and notification. A clustered setup prevents notification outages during instance failures.

Implementation Steps:

  1. Deploy Multiple Instances: Run at least three Alertmanager instances to tolerate node failures.

  2. Cluster Configuration: Use the --cluster.peer flag to form a gossip-based cluster. Example startup command:

     alertmanager \
   --config.file=/etc/alertmanager/config.yml \
   --cluster.listen-address=0.0.0.0:9094 \
   --cluster.peer=alertmanager-1:9094 \
   --cluster.peer=alertmanager-2:9094

  3. Load Balancing: Direct Prometheus instances to all Alertmanagers via a load balancer or DNS-based round-robin:

     alerting:
   alertmanagers:
     - static_configs:
         - targets: ['alertmanager-1:9093', 'alertmanager-2:9093']

Considerations:

  • Gossip Protocol Overhead: Monitor network traffic between Alertmanager nodes in large clusters.

  • State Synchronization: Validate silences and notifications propagate correctly during node restarts.

Strategy 4: Query Federation and Deduplication

A unified query interface aggregates data from multiple Prometheus instances and remote storage, masking underlying infrastructure complexity.

Implementation Steps:

  1. Thanos Query: Deploy Thanos Query as a stateless service that connects to Prometheus instances (via Thanos Sidecar) and/or object storage:

     thanos query \
   --http-address=0.0.0.0:9090 \
   --store=prometheus-1:10901 \
   --store=prometheus-2:10901

  2. Deduplication Rules: Configure --query.replica-label to identify redundant data sources. Thanos Query automatically selects the latest sample during conflicts.

  3. Cortex Querier: If using Cortex, leverage its distributed query engine to execute requests across ingesters and long-term storage.

Considerations:

  • Query Performance: Use caching layers (e.g., Thanos Query Frontend) to accelerate repeated queries.

  • Metadata Handling: Ensure label consistency across instances to avoid query errors.

Best Practices for Operational Robustness

  1. Automated Configuration Management:

    • Use CI/CD pipelines to synchronize configurations across Prometheus and Alertmanager instances.

    • Reload configurations without restarting processes via SIGHUP or HTTP endpoints (/-/reload).

  2. Health Monitoring:

    • Scrape Prometheus self-metrics (e.g., up, prometheus_tsdb_head_samples_appended_total) to detect failures.

    • Monitor Alertmanager cluster health using alertmanager_cluster_health_score.

  3. Failure Testing:

    • Periodically terminate instances to validate failover and recovery procedures.

    • Use chaos engineering tools (e.g., Chaos Mesh, Gremlin) to simulate network partitions or storage outages.

  4. Security Hardening:

    • Encrypt inter-node communication with TLS (e.g., between Thanos components).

    • Restrict access to administrative endpoints (e.g., /-/reload, Thanos Sidecar APIs).

Conclusion

Achieving HA in Prometheus requires a multi-layered approach: redundant data collection, decoupled storage, clustered alert management, and federated querying. While individual strategies can operate independently, combining them provides resilience against diverse failure modes. Adherence to automated configuration, rigorous monitoring, and proactive testing ensures the implementation remains robust under operational stress.

For more technical blogs and in-depth information related to Platform Engineering, please check out the resources available at “https://www.improwised.com/blog/".